Is gap insurance worth it?

Is gap insurance worth it? Only while you owe more than the car is worth. On a $35,000 car bought with nothing down, $3,000 of taxes and fees rolled in and a 72-month loan at 7.5%, the gap peaks near $3,217 and lasts about 3 years; with 20% down and 60 months it never opens.

Calculator

GAP calculator

Loan balance vs. car value, month by month

$
$
$
%
months
Depreciation
$

GAP estimateEstimate

Largest gap$3,217around month 7
Gap after 1 year$3,109
Gap lasts3 yearsuntil the value passes the balance
Amount financed$38,000109% of the price · $657.02/mo
Loan balance (dark) vs. estimated car value (light) at each year end
M12M24M36M48M60M72
Year by year
MonthLoan balanceCar valueGap
Month 12$32,789$29,680$3,109
Month 24$27,173$25,168$2,005
Month 36$21,122$21,342$0
Month 48$14,601$18,098$0
Month 60$7,573$15,347$0
Month 72$0$13,014$0

Value assumes 15.2% depreciation in year 1 and 15.2% a year after (AAA 5-year average). Your insurer pays actual cash value minus your deductible, so the real shortfall is a little larger.

How it is calculated. Loan = price + amount rolled in − down payment, repaid with level monthly payments. Value = price falling at the AAA 5-year average depreciation rate (or your own year-1 and later rates), spread evenly over the months. Gap = balance − value whenever the balance is higher. The insurer pays actual cash value minus your deductible, so the real shortfall is a little larger.

On this page
  1. What is gap insurance?
  2. Is gap insurance worth it for your loan?
  3. How much is gap insurance?
  4. Refunds and pitfalls
  5. FAQ
  6. Sources

What is gap insurance?

GAP (guaranteed asset protection) is an optional product that covers the difference between what you owe on a car loan or lease and what your insurer pays if the car is totaled or stolen, according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.[1] Your own collision or comprehensive pays the car's actual cash value, not the loan balance.[8][9]

  • It is optional. A lender or dealer cannot require you to buy GAP to get an auto loan, and you can decline it.[2][1]
  • Two kinds exist. An insurer can sell GAP insurance with your auto policy, or a dealer can add a GAP waiver (a debt cancellation agreement) to the loan. Maryland's Insurance Administration notes the dealer version is not insurance and is not regulated by it.[7]
  • It needs collision and comprehensive. GAP pays only what is left after those coverages pay.[7]

Is gap insurance worth it for your loan?

Gap insurance is worth it when the calculator shows a large gap for a long time; it is wasted money when the car is worth more than the balance from the start. Three things create a gap: a small down payment, a long term and costs rolled into the loan.

Largest gap for a $35,000 car at 7.5% APR (AAA average depreciation)
LoanAmount financedLargest gapGap lasts
$0 down, $3,000 rolled in, 72 months$38,000$3,21736 months
$0 down, $3,000 rolled in, 48 months$38,000$3,00012 months
$7,000 down, $3,000 rolled in, 60 months$31,000$0no gap
$0 down, $8,000 negative equity rolled in, 84 months$46,000$11,22861 months

Rolling negative equity from a trade-in into a new loan is the fastest way to a big gap: the last row starts more than $11,000 underwater. Depreciation is the other half; new cars lose value fastest in the first years, so switch the calculator to "My own rates" if you expect your model to lose more than the AAA average used here. The car depreciation calculator shows the value curve on its own, and the car lease calculator covers leases, where GAP is often built in.

How much is gap insurance?

How much gap insurance costs depends on who sells it, and no federal agency publishes a national average price. Two things are documented. First, a dealer-sold GAP product is usually added to the loan, so you pay interest on it for the whole term.[1] Second, the CFPB's 2023 lawsuit against one subprime lender alleged an average GAP retail price of about $782 there; that is an allegation about one company, not a market price.[4]

What financing a GAP product costs in total (7.5% APR, 72 months)
GAP price added to the loanTotal paid over the loanOf which interest
$400$498$98
$800$996$196
$1,200$1,494$294

The gap insurance cost to compare with the calculator's "largest gap" is the total paid, not the sticker price. Gap insurance bought from your auto insurer is usually billed with each premium instead of being financed; ask your insurer for the exact amount for your car. The FTC's advice on all car add-ons applies: they are not free, you can ask the price, and you can say no.[6]

Refunds and pitfalls

  • Ask for a refund when the loan ends early. If you sell, refinance or pay off the loan early, you may be entitled to a refund of the unused part of the GAP charge.[1] The CFPB ordered one large auto lender to pay $48 million in redress, partly for failing to make sure customers received GAP refunds.[5]
  • Check the title. CFPB examiners found GAP sold on cars with salvage titles, where the product was void and had no value to the buyer.[3]
  • Know your state's cancel window. Wisconsin, for example, requires a full refund if a GAP waiver is cancelled within 30 days and the price to be shown separately.[10]
  • Ask whether the deductible is covered. If your GAP product does not pay it, the shortfall after a total loss is the gap plus your deductible.

Already paid off the loan, sold the car or had it totaled? The refund kit estimates the unused part of a GAP waiver and a service contract from your contract numbers and fills in the cancellation letters.

Planning the purchase? How much car can I afford checks the payment against income, and what is full coverage car insurance explains the collision and comprehensive a lender will require.

Frequently asked questions

Is gap insurance worth it on a used car?

Only if you owe more than the car is worth, which is less common on used cars because they have already lost much of their value. Run your loan in the calculator: if the largest gap is near zero, skip it.

How much is gap insurance?

Prices vary by seller and no official national average exists. A dealer GAP waiver is usually added to the loan, so its true cost includes interest; insurer-sold GAP is billed with your premium.

Can a dealer make me buy gap insurance?

No. The CFPB says a lender or dealer cannot require GAP to get an auto loan; it is optional.

Do I get a gap insurance refund if I pay off my car early?

Often, for the unused part. Ask the dealer, lender or GAP administrator when you sell, refinance or pay off the loan.

Sources

  1. What is guaranteed asset protection (GAP) insurance? · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, reviewed March 8, 2024
  2. Am I required to purchase an extended warranty or GAP insurance to get an auto loan? · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, accessed November 15, 2026
  3. Supervisory Highlights, Special Edition: Auto Finance (Issue 35) · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, October 2024
  4. Complaint: CFPB and New York v. Credit Acceptance Corporation · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, January 4, 2023 (allegations)
  5. Toyota Motor Credit Corporation (enforcement action) · Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, November 20, 2023
  6. Financing or leasing a car · Federal Trade Commission, July 2022
  7. GAP insurance · Maryland Insurance Administration, accessed November 15, 2026
  8. Auto insurance glossary · Texas Department of Insurance, accessed November 15, 2026
  9. What does auto insurance cover? · National Association of Insurance Commissioners, accessed November 15, 2026
  10. 2017 Wisconsin Act 161 memo (Wis. Stat. 218.0148, GAP waivers) · Wisconsin Legislative Council, 2018