We are not an insurer or broker and are not affiliated with FSRA. Amounts are in Canadian dollars. FSRA's consumer guides are free at fsrao.ca.
Who counts as a high risk driver in Ontario
There is no legal definition of a high risk driver in Ontario: each insurer's approved risk classification system decides who pays more or is declined.[3] The records that typically move a driver into high risk pricing are:
- at-fault accidents (a claim where you were 25% or less at fault cannot be used against you);[2]
- driving convictions, such as speeding, careless driving or impaired driving, and licence suspensions;
- a policy cancelled for non-payment, which can also take away the right to pay in monthly instalments if it happened more than once in 36 months;[2]
- a lapse in coverage, but only in the cases the regulation allows: driving uninsured, cancellation for non-payment, a suspension for a driving conviction, or failing to tell the insurer about an accident or conviction.[2]
Your credit history, income or the fact that you rent cannot make you high risk for a personal car policy.[2]
When an Ontario insurer can cancel your policy
Once a car policy has been in force for more than 60 days, the insurer can cancel it only for one of four reasons.[1]
| Reason | What it means |
|---|---|
| Non-payment | Any part of the premium, or a charge under an agreement tied to the policy, is unpaid |
| False particulars of the car | You gave false details about the described automobile, to the insurer's prejudice |
| Misrepresentation | You knowingly misstated or left out a fact the application asked for |
| Material change in risk | A change covered by the statutory conditions, such as a new use of the car, that you did not report |
An insurer can still decline to renew. A cancellation for non-payment is the record that most often follows a driver into high risk pricing, so if money is tight ask about a monthly plan, which is capped at 1.3% of a 12-month premium (see car insurance rates in Ontario, Canada).[2]
Facility Association Ontario: insurance of last resort
The Facility Association is an association of insurers continued under the Compulsory Automobile Insurance Act, and every insurer is a member.[1] It must run a Plan of Operation that provides car insurance to owners, lessees and licensed drivers who could not otherwise get it, and it must make sure, through its members, that every application submitted under the Plan gets a policy.[1] An agent or broker must give an Ontario owner an application for car insurance and submit it to an insurer when asked.[1]
FSRA describes the Facility Association as an insurance pool that all auto insurers belong to and an insurer of last resort, and it states that the industry as a whole cannot refuse to sell you basic insurance; its consumer line is 1-800-268-9572.[4] FSRA also warns that Facility insurance costs a lot more than regular auto insurance, and it publishes no average Facility premium.[4]
Facility Association premiums are usually much higher than the regular market's. The practical route is to use it to stay insured, keep a clean record, and ask for regular-market quotes again as convictions and claims age out of the insurers' rating periods. Each insurer sets how many years it looks back; ask each one.
Why staying insured matters more than the price
Driving without insurance in Ontario is the most expensive outcome by far.[1]
| Conviction | Fine | Other |
|---|---|---|
| First | $5,000 to $25,000 | Licence suspension of up to one year; the car can be impounded |
| Subsequent | $10,000 to $50,000 | Licence suspension of up to one year; the car can be impounded |
| Presenting a false insurance card | Same as above | Same as above |
A conviction for driving uninsured is also one of the few lapses an insurer may use when rating you later, so it raises the next premium as well; driving without insurance in Ontario covers parents' cars, registration and accidents.[2]
Lowering a high risk premium
The levers on the cheap car insurance Ontario page still work for high risk drivers: a higher deductible, the winter tire discount every insurer must include, telematics, and reviewing optional accident benefits. Choosing a cheaper car to insure also helps; the car affordability calculator lets you budget the premium into the purchase.
Frequently asked questions
Can I be refused car insurance in Ontario?
A single insurer can decline you, but every insurer is a member of the Facility Association, which must provide a policy to drivers who cannot get one elsewhere.
What is the Facility Association in Ontario?
It is the pool of every Ontario auto insurer, set up under the Compulsory Automobile Insurance Act to insure drivers who cannot get a policy elsewhere. You apply through an agent or broker, and the premium is usually far higher than the regular market.
How long do you stay high risk in Ontario?
Each insurer sets how many years of claims and convictions it rates. Ask each insurer, and request regular-market quotes again as your record ages.
Can an insurer cancel my policy for a speeding ticket?
Not after the policy has been in force for 60 days. Cancellation is then limited to non-payment, false particulars, misrepresentation or a material change in risk. The ticket can still raise your renewal.
What is the fine for driving without insurance in Ontario?
$5,000 to $25,000 on a first conviction and $10,000 to $50,000 after that, plus a possible licence suspension of up to a year.