We are not an insurer or broker and are not affiliated with FSRA. Amounts are in Canadian dollars. FSRA's consumer guides are free at fsrao.ca.
The five legal ways to cheaper car insurance in Ontario
The cheapest car insurance in Ontario for a given driver comes from changing what is being insured and how, not from a secret insurer: every insurer prices with its own approved formula, so the same change saves a different amount at each one.[3] The levers you control are:
- Deductible. The default collision and comprehensive deductible is $500; you can choose a higher one for a lower premium.[1] The calculator shows how many claim-free years it takes for the saving to cover the extra out-of-pocket cost.
- Winter tires. Every insurer's rating system must include a discount for a private passenger car with winter tires.[1] The size of the discount is the insurer's own, so ask for it in writing.
- Telematics. Usage-based programs rate the way you actually drive. They are part of the insurer's approved system; ask what happens if your driving data is worse than average.
- Bundling. A multi-policy discount for insuring a home or second car with the same insurer is common but not required by law; home insurance in Ontario shows how to test the bundle on both premiums.
- Optional accident benefits. Since July 1, 2026, income replacement, non-earner, caregiver, housekeeping and home maintenance, death and funeral benefits are offered as optional coverage instead of being automatic.[2]
In the calculator's example the deductible change and two discounts save $451, or 18.8% of a $2,400 premium, and the higher deductible pays back after 4.2 claim-free years.
What cannot make Ontario car insurance cheaper or dearer
Some common pricing factors elsewhere are banned in Ontario, so improving them will not move your car insurance price.[1]
| Factor | Rule |
|---|---|
| Credit history, credit rating, having a credit card | Cannot be used |
| Income, net worth, debts, home ownership | Cannot be used |
| Employment history and occupation | Cannot be used for a personal vehicle |
| A past claim where you were 25% or less at fault | Cannot be used (accidents since September 1, 2010) |
| A gap in coverage | Cannot be used unless you drove uninsured, were cancelled for non-payment, had a driving suspension or hid an accident or conviction |
| Whether you have workplace health or disability benefits | Cannot be used |
Ontario auto insurance reform 2026: optional accident benefits
The Ontario auto insurance reform of July 1, 2026 made every accident benefit except medical, rehabilitation and attendant care optional on new policies, so drivers can now buy less coverage for a lower premium.[4] FSRA's new endorsement for the choice is OPCF 47R, "Optional accident benefits coverage & priority of payment", and insurers must show the premium for each optional coverage or bundle on the quote.[4] An existing policy renews with its pre-July 2026 benefits until you agree in writing to change them, with no deadline; once you opt out, you move to the post-reform coverages and cannot return to the old package.[4]
From July 1, 2026, the benefits in Parts II, IV, V and VI of the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule must be offered as optional benefits with every new or renewed policy; a renewal keeps the benefits you had unless you and the insurer agree in writing to drop or change them.[2] The optional benefits now cover only the named insured, their spouse, their dependants and the drivers listed on the policy.[2] Medical, rehabilitation and attendant care stay in every policy, up to $65,000 for a non-catastrophic injury or $1,000,000 for a catastrophic one, and you can buy higher limits.[2]
Optional accident benefits in Ontario cost little next to the main premium, but they pay real money after a crash, which is why the decision deserves a line-by-line look. Declining income replacement saves premium, but if you have no disability coverage at work, a serious crash could leave you without income. Enter the quoted saving in the calculator only after comparing it with what you would lose. The rates side, including the cap on monthly plans, is on the car insurance rates in Ontario, Canada page; drivers with convictions or cancellations should read high risk car insurance in Ontario. Prices in the GTA run highest; see car insurance in Toronto for the regional averages.
The same deductible arithmetic applies in the U.S.; compare with how much car insurance costs in the U.S. if you are moving across the border.
Frequently asked questions
How can I get cheap car insurance in Ontario?
Ask for the winter tire discount, compare a higher deductible against the saving, consider telematics and bundling, and review which optional accident benefits you need. Then compare quotes for the same coverage from several insurers.
Is the winter tire discount mandatory in Ontario?
Insurers must include a winter tire discount for private passenger cars in their rating systems for policies issued or renewed since January 1, 2016. The amount is set by each insurer.
Should I drop optional accident benefits to save money?
Only if other coverage, such as workplace disability insurance, would replace them. Medical, rehabilitation and attendant care remain in every policy.
What are optional accident benefits in Ontario?
Since July 1, 2026 they are income replacement, non-earner, caregiver, housekeeping and home maintenance, death and funeral benefits, plus higher limits. They are offered with every policy and you choose which to buy; medical, rehabilitation and attendant care stay mandatory.
What changed in the Ontario auto insurance reform 2026?
New policies from July 1, 2026 include only medical, rehabilitation and attendant care as mandatory accident benefits; the rest are optional (OPCF 47R). Existing policies keep their old benefits at renewal until you agree in writing to change them.
What is the cheapest car insurance in Ontario?
There is no single cheapest insurer for everyone: each one uses its own approved formula. The same driver can get very different quotes, so compare at least three for identical coverage.
Sources
- R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 664, Automobile Insurance (ss. 3, 5.2, 14.1, 16)
- O. Reg. 34/10, Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule (s. 2 optional benefits from July 1, 2026; ss. 18, 28)
- Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. I.8 (s. 251 minimum liability; s. 410 rate and risk classification approval)
- Changes to Statutory Accident Benefits coverage in Ontario, July 1, 2026 (OPCF 47R) and insurer Q&A