Car insurance Toronto: what GTA drivers pay

Car insurance in Toronto and the rest of the Greater Toronto Area averaged $2,810 a year, about $234 a month, as of October 2025, according to Ontario's regulator FSRA. That is 29.9% above the provincial average of $2,164. FSRA publishes no separate figure for the city of Toronto or for Brampton.

Calculator

Toronto car insurance check

Your quote or renewal against the FSRA GTA average, in Canadian dollars

$
Policy term
$
$

Ontario premium check (CAD)Estimate

Premium for the year$3,000.00$250.00 a month before any instalment charge
Change from last term+$200+7.1%
Most a monthly plan may add$39.001.3% of the premium (Reg. 664)
Monthly payment at that cap$253.2512 payments
Premium on the quote$3,000.00
Maximum instalment charge$39.00
Most you pay on a monthly plan$3,039.00

FSRA's average annual premium in the GTA was $2,810 as of October 2025. Your premium is $190 (6.8%) above it. The average mixes every driver, car and coverage level, so being above it is not proof of overpaying.

Your premium went up 7.1%. Ask the insurer which rating factor changed (a claim, a conviction, a new driver, the car, your address) or whether it was a rate change approved by FSRA; you can also ask for the rating details in writing.

Amounts in Canadian dollars. The cap applies when the insurer has to offer monthly payments (private passenger policies of insurers with 10,000 or more Ontario cars, premium over $300); an insurer can charge less or nothing.

How it is calculated. Comparison = your premium for a year − FSRA's average annual premium for the region (GTA $2,810, October 2025). Change = new premium − last premium. Maximum instalment charge = premium × 1.3% for a 12-month term (0.65% for 6–11 months), Reg. 664, s. 3 (5.2). The average mixes every driver, car and coverage level; it is a reference, not a price for you.

On this page
  1. Average car insurance in Toronto and the GTA
  2. Why car insurance costs more in Toronto
  3. Car insurance in Brampton and the rest of the GTA
  4. Rules that are the same in Toronto as everywhere in Ontario
  5. FAQ
  6. Sources

We are not an insurer or broker and are not affiliated with FSRA. Amounts are in Canadian dollars. FSRA's consumer guides are free at fsrao.ca.

Average car insurance in Toronto and the GTA

The Greater Toronto Area is the most expensive of the three regions FSRA reports: $2,810 a year on average as of October 2025, against $2,076 in other urban areas and $1,740 in rural Ontario.[1] The figure is the average annual premium of all private passenger vehicles insured over the previous 12 months, so it blends new and experienced drivers, old and new cars, and minimum and full coverage.[1]

Average annual car insurance premium by Ontario region, C$ (FSRA "Your average premium", as of October 2025)
RegionAs of June 2024As of October 2024As of June 2025As of October 2025Per month (latest)
Ontario (all regions)$1,927$2,006$2,120$2,164$180
Greater Toronto Area (GTA)$2,543$2,638$2,765$2,810$234
Other urban Ontario$1,842$1,918$2,031$2,076$173
Rural Ontario$1,521$1,592$1,698$1,740$145

In the calculator's example, a $3,000 quote is $190 (6.8%) above the GTA average, and paying it monthly can add at most $39.00. Being above the average is not proof of overpaying: a young driver or a new car will usually be above it. The province-wide view, with every rule that sets a premium, is on car insurance rates in Ontario, Canada.

Why car insurance costs more in Toronto

Where the car is kept is one of the rating factors FSRA lists, and it says rates are usually higher in urban areas.[2] Each insurer divides Ontario into its own rating territories and has that risk classification system, and the rates for each territory, approved by FSRA before use.[3] That is why two Toronto quotes for the same driver and car can be far apart: each insurer's approved formula weighs the GTA differently. The other factors FSRA lists apply in Toronto as anywhere: the car, your driving record and years licensed, age, kilometres driven and commuting, coverage and deductible.[2]

How the GTA average compares (FSRA, October 2025)
ComparisonDifference a yearDifference
GTA vs. all of Ontario$64629.9%
GTA vs. other urban Ontario$73435.4%
GTA vs. rural Ontario$1,07061.5%
GTA, October 2025 vs. October 2024$1726.5%
GTA, October 2025 vs. June 2024$26710.5%

Car insurance in Brampton and the rest of the GTA

Car insurance in Brampton uses the same official reference as Toronto: FSRA's GTA average of $2,810 a year, because the regulator publishes no figure for Brampton or any other single city.[1] The Greater Toronto Area is usually taken to mean the City of Toronto and the regions of Durham, Halton, Peel (which includes Brampton and Mississauga) and York; FSRA does not publish which postal codes its GTA figure covers. Any "Brampton average" you see elsewhere comes from a private quote sample, not from the regulator.

What helps a Brampton or Toronto driver most is the same: compare at least three quotes for identical coverage, ask each insurer for its winter tire discount, which every rating system must include, and test a higher deductible against the saving.[4] The cheap car insurance Ontario calculator applies those changes to your own premium.

Rules that are the same in Toronto as everywhere in Ontario

Living in Toronto changes the price, not the law: every Ontario policy needs at least $200,000 of third-party liability, and insurers may not use your credit history, income, home ownership or a claim where you were 25% or less at fault to rate a personal car policy.[3][4] A monthly plan can add at most 1.3% of a 12-month premium.[4] Driving without insurance carries a fine of $5,000 to $25,000 on a first conviction.[5] Drivers with convictions or a cancellation should read high risk car insurance in Ontario, and the cost of running the car beyond insurance is in the gas cost calculator.

Frequently asked questions

How much is car insurance in Toronto?

FSRA's average for the Greater Toronto Area was $2,810 a year, about $234 a month, as of October 2025. There is no official figure for the city alone, and your own price depends on your car, record and coverage.

Why is car insurance so expensive in Brampton?

Brampton is in the GTA, the Ontario region with the highest average premium, and FSRA notes that urban rates are usually higher. Each insurer prices its Brampton territory with its own approved formula, so quotes vary widely.

Is car insurance cheaper outside the GTA?

On average, yes: $2,076 in other urban areas and $1,740 in rural Ontario, against $2,810 in the GTA (FSRA, October 2025). Your rate follows where the car is kept, and giving a false address is misrepresentation, a reason an insurer may cancel.

What is the cheapest car insurance in Toronto, Ontario?

No insurer is cheapest for everyone, because each uses its own FSRA-approved formula. Compare several quotes for the same coverage and deductible, and apply the discounts you are offered.

Sources

  1. Your average premium (average annual premium by region, as of October 2025) · Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA); archived copy of June 23, 2026, read November 15, 2026
  2. What determines your auto insurance rate · Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA); archived copy of March 22, 2026, read November 15, 2026
  3. Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. I.8 (s. 251 minimum liability; s. 410 rate and risk classification approval) · Government of Ontario, e-Laws (consolidated January 1, 2026), read November 15, 2026
  4. R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 664, Automobile Insurance (ss. 3, 5.2, 14.1, 16) · Government of Ontario, e-Laws (consolidated July 1, 2026), read November 15, 2026
  5. Compulsory Automobile Insurance Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.25 (ss. 2, 5, 7, 12) · Government of Ontario, e-Laws, read November 15, 2026